Scratch on the 8 Ball: Do You Lose? 7 Rules for Every Case

Quick answer: If you scratch on the 8 ball and the 8 goes in, you lose. If you scratch on the 8 ball and the 8 stays up, it depends on the rules. Under BCA and the official rules, it is not a loss. Your opponent gets ball in hand. Under APA, TAP and bar rules, any scratch on the 8 ball is a loss.

scratch on the 8 ball diagram: the cue ball hits the 8 ball and goes in a pocket, BCA gives ball in hand if the 8 stays up, APA, TAP and bar rules call it a loss
Scratch on the 8 ball: if the 8 goes in, you lose. If the 8 stays up, it depends on the rules you play.

You ran all your balls. Now you are on the 8. You shoot, and the cue ball drops in a pocket. Do you lose? Readers of my Billiards Planet newsletter have asked me this more than once. My answer is always the same: it depends on which rules you are playing.

I have played pool for over 50 years, and I have played in leagues and tournaments for over 38 years. This page goes deep on just this one question. For scratches in general, see our pool scratch rules page.

Scratch on the 8 Ball: 7 Rules to Know

Rule 1: What Counts as a Scratch on the 8 Ball

A scratch is when the cue ball goes in a pocket. Under the official rules, it is also a foul if the cue ball touches a ball that is already in the pocket. A scratch on the 8 ball means you scratch while you are shooting at the 8.

Here is a tricky part. In APA, it does not matter if the cue ball hits the 8 ball or not. Any scratch while you shoot at the 8 counts.

Rule 2: BCA and Official Rules: The 8 Stays Up

Under the official 8 ball rules, when you shoot at the 8 ball, a scratch or foul is not loss of game if the 8 is not pocketed or knocked off the table. Your opponent gets cue ball in hand. That means they can put the cue ball anywhere on the table and shoot. In the BCA league, it is not a loss if you scratch on the 8 ball but do not pocket the 8. Learn more on our ball in hand rules page.

Rule 3: Make the 8 Ball and Scratch: You Lose

The official rules say you lose the game if you foul when you pocket the 8 ball. So if the 8 goes in and the cue ball goes in too, the game is over. To the best of my knowledge, when you pocket the 8 ball and scratch, it is always a loss. The one exception is the break (see Rule 7).

Playing a side game, like bank the 8? If you both agree on a different rule before you start, that can change it. Agree first, not after the shot.

Rule 4: APA and TAP: Any Scratch on the 8 Ball Is a Loss

In APA and TAP leagues, any scratch on the 8 is a loss. It does not matter if the 8 went in or not. This is the most common rule in 8 ball. If you play in a league, check your rule book.

Rule 5: Bar Rules: Same as APA

Bar rules, also called straight 8, are the same as APA and TAP on this one. Scratch on the 8 and you lose. Bar rules also ask you to call banks, kisses and caroms. If you call the 8 in the corner clean and it touches a ball or a rail on the way in, you lose the game. Read more about bar rules on our billiard rules page.

Rule 6: Table Scratch on the 8 Ball

A table scratch is a foul where the cue ball stays on the table, like missing the 8 ball, or no ball touching a rail after the hit. Under the official rules, a foul while you shoot at the 8 is not a loss if the 8 stays on the table. Your opponent gets ball in hand.

In bar rules, there is no penalty for missing a ball or a rail. A table foul is only loss of turn, and the cue ball is left where it stops. For a table foul on the 8 in an APA or TAP league, check your league rule book.

Rule 7: Scratch on the 8 Ball on the Break

The break is the one time you can make the 8 and scratch and not lose under the official rules. If the breaker makes the 8 and scratches on the break, the other player chooses. They can rerack, or spot the 8 and shoot with ball in hand behind the head string.

APA is different. You can win or lose the game on the break in APA. If you make the 8 on the break and scratch, you lose the game in APA. See more on our how to break in pool page.

Other Ways to Lose the Game on the 8 Ball

Under the official rules, you also lose if you:

  • Make the 8 ball on the same shot as the last ball of your group.
  • Knock the 8 ball off the table at any time.
  • Make the 8 ball in a pocket you did not call.
  • Make the 8 ball when it is not your legal ball yet.

Also, a combination shot can never be used to legally make the 8 ball. And all fouls must be called before the next shot, or they do not count. Read all of them on our official billiard rules and 8 ball rules pages.

How to Avoid a Scratch on the 8 Ball

Many times a player runs all of their balls, then misses the money ball or scratches. Most of the time it is because they did not think about where the cue ball was going. Here is what I teach in my book:

  • Always play shape when you shoot the 8. Every shot in pool is two jobs: make the ball and get position.
  • Play the cue ball to a spot on the rail when you pocket the 8 ball.
  • Do not think, "I hope I do not scratch." Thoughts like that almost always bring the exact result you are trying to stop. Think about the shot you want, and see it happen in your mind first.

Learn to send the cue ball where you want it on our cue ball control and stop shot in pool pages.

In the video below, I run a rack of 8 ball. Watch how I play the cue ball so I stay in line for the 8, then finish the rack on the 8 ball.

Scratch on the 8 Ball Rules: Ask Before You Break

A scratch on the 8 ball can win or lose a game, so know the rule before the first break. Ask, "What rules are we playing?" Is a scratch on the 8 a loss, or only if the 8 goes in? You can read my answers to readers on this in Billiards Planet 007-A.

Win More Games of 8 Ball

Getting to the 8 ball is only half the job. My book 8 Ball Winning Strategies shows you how to plan your rack so you get to the 8 with an easy shot. Learn more on our 8 Ball Winning Strategies page, or read our 8 ball strategy tips.

Learn the Fundamentals Free

Our free 7 part pool fundamentals course covers stance, bridge, stroke, and more, one lesson at a time by email. Sign up on our free pool lessons page.

Scratch on the 8 Ball FAQ

Do you lose if you scratch on the 8 ball?

It depends on the rules. Under BCA and the official rules, you lose only if the 8 ball goes in. If the 8 stays on the table, your opponent gets ball in hand. In APA, TAP and bar rules, any scratch on the 8 ball is a loss.

What happens if you scratch on the 8 ball but it does not go in?

Under the official rules, it is a foul but not a loss. Your opponent gets ball in hand anywhere on the table. In APA, TAP and bar rules, it is still a loss.

What happens if you make the 8 ball and scratch?

You lose the game. The one time this is not a loss under the official rules is on the break. If you make the 8 and scratch on the break, your opponent can rerack, or spot the 8 and shoot with ball in hand behind the head string.

Do you lose if you scratch on the break in 8 ball?

Under the official rules, no. A scratch on the break is a foul and your opponent gets ball in hand behind the head string. In APA, if you make the 8 on the break and scratch, you lose.

Know someone who argues about pool rules? Post this scratch on the 8 ball page on X.